May 10, 2025

Fire Pit Face-Off: Wood-Burning vs. Gas vs. Bioethanol

Choosing the ultimate backyard fire pit? Quick answer: wood crackles, gas clicks, bioethanol flickers. Each one offers a unique experience—perfect for different vibes and occasions. Wondering which one will be the perfect fit for your garden? Keep reading as we break down the pros, cons, and safety tips for wood-burning, gas, and bioethanol fire pits. Our Outdoor Heating and Firepits Collection has everything you need to make an informed decision.

Comparing Fuel Types and Features of Fire Pits

When it comes to fire pits, the type of fuel you use plays a massive role in both the performance and your overall experience. From the traditional, warm embrace of wood to the effortless click of gas or the eco-friendly flicker of bioethanol, your choice shapes the atmosphere of your outdoor space.

Let’s compare the three most popular types—wood-burning, gas, and bioethanol fire pits. We’ll explore their benefits, challenges, and the features you need to know to help you make the right decision.

Wood-Burning Fire Pits

There's something undeniably special about a wood-burning fire pit. Think of sitting around a crackling fire, surrounded by the scent of burning logs and the warmth that only real wood can provide. Whether you're toasting marshmallows or just enjoying a chat with friends, wood-burning fire pits bring an authentic charm to your garden that is hard to beat.

Pros: Authentic Ambiance, Natural Crackling Sound, Intense Heat

When you think of a fire pit, the image of roaring flames and crackling logs probably springs to mind. Wood-burning pits offer that quintessential experience—nothing beats the smell of wood smoke and the sound of the fire popping. Not only does this provide an atmosphere like no other, but wood fires also offer some serious heat, making them perfect for chilly evenings. Whether you’re hosting a garden party or simply unwinding, the intense warmth of a wood-burning fire pit will keep you snug.

Cons: Smoke Production, Need for Wood Storage, Ash Cleanup, Potential for Embers

But, like all good things, there’s a bit of effort involved. Wood-burning fire pits create smoke, which can be a downside for some, especially if you live in an area with restrictions on burning or if you're sensitive to the smell. Plus, you’ll need to store your wood somewhere dry, which can take up space and requires a bit of planning. And then there's the ash—while it’s great for creating that rustic fire pit vibe, cleaning up the aftermath isn’t always as charming. Lastly, keep in mind the risk of embers flying out of the pit, potentially setting your surroundings alight.

Safety Concerns (Embers, Open Flame)

One thing to always keep in mind with wood-burning fire pits is safety. The open flame and flying embers mean you need to position the pit carefully—far from fences, trees, or your house. Even with a safety screen, it’s important to always monitor the fire to prevent accidents.

Gas Fire Pits

If you're after a fire pit that requires minimal effort but still delivers a great experience, then a gas fire pit might be more your speed. With gas, you get the heat and ambience of a fire without all the hassle of chopping wood or cleaning ash. Plus, lighting it up is as simple as flicking a switch or pressing a button.

Pros: Convenience (Instant On/Off), Adjustable Flame Height, Cleaner Burning (Less Smoke), Variety of Designs

The main advantage of gas fire pits is the convenience. Want a fire without the faff? Just turn it on and voilà. Many gas fire pits also allow you to adjust the flame height, giving you control over the level of heat and the ambiance. They're also far cleaner than wood, producing almost no smoke—ideal for those who dislike the smell of burning wood or live in areas with smoke regulations. Gas fire pits come in various designs, from sleek, modern styles to more traditional, rustic options, so you can find something that fits your garden aesthetic.

Cons: Less Authentic Feel for Some, Requires Gas Line or Propane Tank, Can Be More Expensive Initially

While gas fire pits are incredibly convenient, they don’t quite offer the same authentic experience that wood-burning fire pits provide. Some people prefer the natural crackle of a log burning rather than a gas flame, which can feel less "real". You’ll also need a gas connection, either from a natural gas line or a propane tank, which adds an extra layer of setup and cost. And while gas fire pits are low maintenance, the initial investment can be higher than their wood-burning counterparts.

Bioethanol Fire Pits

For a modern, eco-friendly twist on the traditional fire pit, bioethanol might be the answer. These fire pits burn alcohol-based fuel, producing clean, smokeless flames that are perfect for more contemporary spaces. Plus, bioethanol fire pits are portable, so you can move them around your garden or even bring them indoors.

Pros: Portable, No Smoke or Ash, Relatively Clean Burning, Modern Aesthetics

Bioethanol fire pits are perfect for those who want a sleek, minimalist aesthetic in their outdoor space. Because they don’t produce smoke or ash, they’re incredibly low-maintenance and won’t leave you with a mess to clean up afterwards. Plus, bioethanol burns cleanly, so they’re an eco-friendly option. Their modern designs can really elevate the look of your garden, creating a stylish, contemporary vibe that fits with a variety of decor styles.

Cons: Lower Heat Output Compared to Wood or Gas, Fuel Can Be More Expensive, Flame May Be Less Visually Dramatic

However, bioethanol fire pits do have some limitations. While they’re perfect for adding a beautiful focal point to your garden, they tend to produce less heat than wood or gas fire pits. So, if you're hoping for a roaring fire to warm up a large group, bioethanol might not cut it. Additionally, the cost of bioethanol fuel can be higher compared to wood or gas, and the flame itself is typically smaller and less dramatic, which could be a dealbreaker for those craving a more powerful fire.

Which Fire Pit is Right for You?

Now that we’ve weighed up the pros and cons of wood-burning, gas, and bioethanol fire pits, it’s clear that each has its own strengths and weaknesses. The best choice for you depends on your preferences, lifestyle, and how you plan to use your fire pit.

Wood-burning is perfect for those who want an authentic, rustic experience and don’t mind a bit of effort.
Gas is ideal for those who want convenience, control over the flame, and a cleaner burn with less mess.
Bioethanol is the go-to for eco-conscious individuals who love modern aesthetics and portability but don’t need a massive heat output.

No matter which option you choose, a fire pit will transform your garden into a cosy retreat. So, light up your evenings and enjoy a fire that suits your style!

Other articles our customers have found useful:

Previous article Finding the Right Spot: Safely Positioning Your Garden Fire Pit

Next article Powering Your Pergola Comfort: Energy Consumption Considerations