Pergola and awning side-by-side in a backyard.

March 11, 2025

Awning vs. Pergola: Which One Is Cheaper & Best for Your Home?

Want shade without draining your wallet? Awnings are cheaper upfront, but aluminium pergolas offer better longevity. Don’t jump to conclusions just yet! From hidden costs to long-term value, we’re breaking down which option gives you the best mix of style, durability, and savings. Let’s settle this debate!

Awning vs. Pergola: The Cheaper Option for Shade & Style

Understanding Your Shade Options

What is an Awning?

An awning is a simple yet effective way to add shade to your outdoor space. It extends over patios, doors, or windows, protecting you from harsh sunlight and light rain. More than just practical, it can also enhance the look of your home’s exterior.

Awnings come in various styles, but the two main types are retractable and fixed.

Retractable Awnings vs. Fixed Awnings

Retractable Awnings – Ideal for flexible shade. Extend them on hot days, retract them when you want sunshine.
Fixed Awnings – A permanent solution that offers constant shade but lacks adaptability in changing weather.

Material Options for Awnings

Awnings are available in different materials, each offering unique benefits:

Fabric – Canvas, polyester, or acrylic for a softer look and UV protection.
Metal – Aluminium or steel for durability and a modern aesthetic.
Polycarbonate Panels – Sturdy, weather-resistant, and often translucent for soft lighting.

What is a Pergola?

A pergola is a stylish outdoor structure designed to provide partial shade. With an open, slatted roof, it allows natural light to filter through while creating a defined outdoor space. Unlike an awning, a pergola feels more like an extension of your home, making it a favourite for garden lovers.

There are two main styles to choose from: open-air and covered.

Open-Air Pergolas vs. Covered Pergolas

Open-Air Pergolas – Feature spaced-out beams, allowing sunlight and airflow.
Covered Pergolas – Designed with polycarbonate panels, fabric, or retractable canopies for extra weather protection.

Material Options for Pergolas

Pergolas come in a range of materials, each affecting cost and upkeep:

Wood – A classic, natural look but requires regular maintenance.
Metal – Aluminium or steel for a modern, low-maintenance option.
Vinyl – A durable, weather-resistant choice with minimal upkeep.

Key Differences at a Glance

Feature	Awning	Pergola
Cost	Lower upfront cost	Higher initial cost
Installation	Quick & easy	More complex
Shade Control	Retractable options	Fixed or adjustable
Durability	10–15 years	15–25 years
Aesthetic	Functional, limited	Stylish, adds value

Cost Breakdown: Awnings vs. Pergolas

Initial Installation Costs

Material Costs Comparison

Awnings – Prices range from £300 – £3,000, depending on size and material.
Pergolas – Costs start at £1,000 and can go beyond £10,000 for high-end designs.

Labour Costs for Installation

Awnings – Professional installation typically costs between £100 – £500.
Pergolas – Due to the complexity, installation can range from £500 – £3,000.

Long-Term Expenses

Maintenance and Repairs

Awnings – Fabric awnings need replacing every 5–10 years.
Pergolas – Wooden pergolas need sealing or repainting, while metal and vinyl versions are lower maintenance.

Energy Savings

Awnings help reduce cooling costs by blocking direct sunlight, which can make them a great money-saver in warm climates.

Property Value Impact

Pergolas add a stylish touch to a home’s exterior, potentially increasing resale value.

Shade and Weather Protection

Shade Effectiveness

Sun Protection and UV Blocking

Awnings provide complete shade, while pergolas offer a more dappled effect unless fitted with a cover.

Temperature Reduction

Awnings significantly lower temperatures by blocking direct sunlight, making patios and interior spaces cooler.

Weather Resistance

Rain and Snow Protection

Awnings – Effective for rain, but heavy snow can cause damage.
Pergolas – Sturdier but need additional coverings for full rain protection.

Wind Resistance

Awnings can be retracted during strong winds, while pergolas need strong anchoring to withstand harsh weather.

Style and Aesthetic Appeal: Enhancing Your Backyard Design

Curb Appeal and Home Value

Pergolas often enhance a home’s value more than awnings due to their architectural beauty.

Design Versatility

Customisation Options for Awnings

Wide range of fabric colours and patterns.
Motorised vs. manual operation.
Optional LED lighting integration.

Customisation Options for Pergolas

Built-in seating, planters, or lighting.
Retractable canopies for adjustable shade.
Climbing plants like wisteria or ivy for a natural touch.

Integrating with Outdoor Living Spaces

Pergolas create a defined outdoor room, perfect for entertaining, while awnings offer flexible shade over patios and decks.

Installation and Maintenance: Ease of Use

Installation Process

DIY vs. Professional Installation

Awnings – Easier to install, making them a good DIY option.
Pergolas – Typically require professional installation due to their size and complexity.

Permitting and Regulations

In some areas, pergolas require planning permission, whereas awnings usually do not.

Maintenance Requirements

Awnings need occasional cleaning and fabric replacement.
Pergolas, especially wooden ones, require periodic treatment to withstand the elements.

Longevity and Durability

Metal and vinyl pergolas last significantly longer than fabric awnings.

Pros and Cons: Making the Right Choice

Advantages of Awnings

✔ Lower cost.
✔ Quick and easy to install.
✔ Excellent sun protection.

Disadvantages of Awnings

✘ Shorter lifespan.
✘ Limited design appeal.
✘ Prone to wind damage.

Advantages of Pergolas

✔ Adds beauty and value to your home.
✔ More durable over time.
✔ Can be customised for year-round use.

Disadvantages of Pergolas

✘ Higher initial cost.
✘ Requires maintenance.
✘ Less effective for full sun blockage without a cover.

Factors to Consider: Tailoring to Your Needs

Climate and Weather Conditions

Awnings suit hot, sunny areas, while pergolas are better for long-term durability.

Available Space and Layout

Awnings work well in compact spaces, whereas pergolas require more room.

Budget and Financial Planning

Awnings are the more affordable upfront choice, while pergolas offer a better return on investment.

Personal Preferences and Lifestyle

If you entertain often, a pergola provides a stylish outdoor retreat. If you need quick, practical shade, an awning is the way to go.

Which is the Cheaper Option?

Summarising the Cost Comparison

Awnings are the most budget-friendly upfront, while pergolas require a larger investment but offer longer-lasting benefits.

Best Value for Your Investment

Choose an awning if affordability and practicality are your top priorities.
Opt for a pergola if you want a more permanent, stylish feature that adds value to your home.

Conclusion: Creating Your Ideal Outdoor Shade Solution

Both options have their strengths. Awnings are cost-effective and easy to install, while pergolas elevate your outdoor space with style and longevity. The best choice depends on your budget, needs, and vision for your outdoor area.

What’s your pick—practical shade or long-term charm?

Other articles our customers have found useful: